Skip to main content

Michael Drayton V/S Amitabh Bhattacharya

Hello friends,
Today I was reading a poem which I studied during my graduation “Since There’s No Help” by Michael Drayton. While reading this poem, I heard a song playing in my neighbourhood. The song was “Breakup song” from the latest Bollywood movie “Ae Dil hai Mushkil”. I thought to compare both the writers and their work.



Let’s first know something about both the writers



Both the works are written in an different era, for different generation and by different generation poets.
Let’s first see the poem and song and its analysis:-

Since there's no help, come let us kiss and part - Michael Drayton

Since there's no help, come let us kiss and part.
Nay, I have done, you get no more of me;
And I am glad, yea glad with all my heart,
That thus so cleanly I myself can free.
Shake hands for ever, cancel all our vows,
And when we meet at any time again,
Be it not seen in either of our brows
That we one jot of former love retain.
Now at the last gasp of Love's latest breath,
When, his pulse failing, Passion speechless lies;
When Faith is kneeling by his bed of death,
And Innocence is closing up his eyes-
Now, if thou wouldst, when all have given him over,
From death to life thou might'st him yet recover!

The goodbye kiss is always a painful event, but in some ways, it is a relief.  Drayton captures both those feelings in this sonnet.

In the first eight lines, Drayton appears to be quite relieved to be windup this relationship.  Basically, he says, "Since there's nothing we can do to stop this breakup, let's kiss, make an end of it. We will not see one another.  I'm happy to be free.  We can shake hands, and when we meet again, it'll be like we have no love left for one another. There will be no hint of it at all."  That sounds great, honestly.  But does it ever really happen that way?
"I am glad, yea, glad with all my heart that thus so cleanly I myself can free."

From a modern point of view, we can say that it’s a happy moment to be free from the web of relations. But it seems that Drayton is trying hard to make himself understand that he is happy about the breakup.

 "Be it not seen in either of our brows that we one jot of former love retain."
Is it really possible to pretend that we don’t know a person with whom we were in relationship once upon a time.
The last six lines are at odds with the first eight.
The first eight are the mind's explanation of the breakup. 

So the poet here pretends to be but he is not happy as such. It is true that it is not easy to break up any relation and move on. Especially when you love someone. But from modern time if we see then it is not suitable.

The contemporary time allow one to be free from the conspicuous cobweb of relations.

Here is an audio clip of this song also.





Here in this song we see the reality of the present time. It is age of quick patch-up and quick break-up. In the people used to cry a lot when any relationship breaks, but now when someone is breaking up people to go to parlour of a hair-wash. In the present time we have many options to let our frustration fly away. We can block people and delete their number.
The status on the social media tells about our relations are we single or available or committed. Its so easy we can change our relation status whenever we like.

Of course this song reflects the present time of society and it seems very funny but that is the reality.
We can also go deep into it and can see that the meaning of love is somewhere lost in this present time. Somewhere there is a need to understand love and life.

We can also see a theme of Necessity V/S Absurdity here. Michael Drayton highlights the necessity of relation and love, while Amitabh Bhattacharya highlights the absurdity of relation and love.

Both the poem and the song reflect the reality of their time. The message given in the both the works are realistic. It is always hard to break any relation and pretend that everything is okay. But to keep a hopeless hope that everything will be fine is also sometimes stupid. We have to move on and focus on something else, rather than crying for the rotten relation.

 “Change is the law of life. And those who look only to the past or the present are certain to miss the future.”     ― John F. Kennedy

The best thing to do is to “Go with the flow”. Accept whatever comes with the flow.

Hope you enjoyed reading!!!!

Please give your observations and suggestions.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

"RIP"; Rest in Peace those who are Alive....

Hello Friends, After a long time I am writing here. Hope you all are fine. This time I have come up with a different interpretation of the phrase “RIP”. Mostly this phrase “RIP”; Rest in Peace is used for the people who are no more. We use this phrase to give sympathy towards the departed soul. The soul may get peace wherever it travels. No one exactly knows where the soul travels. Sometimes this phrase is used out of care and sometimes just for show off on social media. While sitting alone near a cemetery, a thought struck in my mind. Why do we use RIP only for dead people????? We can also use it for those who are alive. Many time people use RIP when a person is dead. The same people might have harassed the dead person when he is alive. So what’s the point of “RIP”? Suppose in the day time you behave very badly with someone. Is he/she going to get sound and peaceful sleep at night? The dead person will never come back so we just say “RIP”. Of course ever
Post a Comment
Read more

“My friend, the things that do attain” - Henry Howard, Earl of Surrey.

Hello friends, I would like to share a poem which I studied during my graduation. The title of the poem is “My friend, the things that do attain”. It is written by Henry Howard, Earl of Surrey. Henry Howard, Earl of Surrey (1516/1517 – 19 January 1547), was an English aristocrat, and one of the founders of English Renaissance poetry. MY friend, the things that do attain The happy life be these, I find: The riches left, not got with pain; The fruitful ground; the quiet mind; The equal friend; no grudge; no strife; No charge of rule, nor governance; Without disease, the healthy life; The household of continuance; The mean diet, no dainty fare; Wisdom joined with simpleness; The night discharged of all care, Where wine the wit may not oppress: The faithful wife, without debate; Such sleeps as may beguile the night; Content thyself with thine estate, Neither wish death, nor fear his might. In the above mentioned poem, there is a list
3 comments
Read more

" The Winged Word"- David Green

In my Graduation syllabus, I had a book named “ The Winged word”. This anthology is edited by David Green. It is anthology of poems compiled for the students of English literature in the B.A courses of Indian Universities. The chronological order, in which the poets are arranged in this book, helps the students to note the development of English poetry from one age to another. Referring to this book after a long time span, gives me a immense joy. There are many poems in this book. We were given some selected poems to study during three years of graduation. The poems which were in my syllabus are as follow:-    1.)   I Find No Peace – Sir Thomas Wyatt (1503-42)    2.) My Friend, the Things That Do Attain –Henry Howard (1517- 47)    3.) The Nymph’s Reply to the Shepherd –Sir Walter Ralegh (1552-1618)    4.) The Nightingale – Sir Philip Sidney (1554- 86)    5.) Since There’s No Help – Michael Drayton (1563- 1613)    6.) Sonnet No.116 – Willi
5 comments
Read more